Document Category: Child Sexual Abuse
| Title | Content | Date Filed | Jurisdiction | Categories | Link | hf:doc_author | hf:doc_categories |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appellate Brief Challenging Admission of CSAAS-Type Expert Testimony | This appellate brief argues that testimony concerning delayed disclosure, grooming, recantation, and other behaviors commonly associated with Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome (CSAAS) fails to satisfy Daubert and 702 because it is not based on reliable data, methodology, or scientific principles. The brief explains that CSAAS was developed as a therapeutic framework rather than a diagnostic tool and assumes abuse occurred rather than helping determine whether abuse occurred. Relying on contemporary research, it argues that many claims about delayed disclosure, denial, and recantation are unsupported or overstated and that such testimony often reinforces juror misconceptions rather than correcting them. | November 1, 2025 | Michigan, National | 403, Child Sexual Abuse, Evidence, Expert Testimony, Witnesses | michigan national | 403 testimony-about-child-sexual-abuse evidence expert-testimony witnesses | |
| Amicus Brief Challenging Admission of Penile Plethysmograph Evidence in Sexually Violent Predator Proceedings | This amicus brief urges courts to adopt a general presumption against admitting penile plethysmograph (PPG) evidence in sexually violent predator proceedings. It argues that PPG testing lacks scientific rigor and standardization, is vulnerable to manipulation, and depends on unsupported assumptions that physiological response reliably reflects subjective sexual arousal and predicts future criminal conduct. Because the procedure appears scientific, the brief warns that factfinders may give unreliable results undue weight, particularly in proceedings already marked by substantial stigma and prejudice. The brief also argues that compelled PPG testing implicates fundamental rights to bodily and mental integrity and raises First Amendment concerns by treating private thoughts or physiological responses as evidence of future conduct. Given that SVP commitment may result in indefinite confinement, the brief contends that heightened due-process protections are required and analogizes PPG testing to polygraph evidence, urging a consistent, bright-line presumption of inadmissibility that would protect individual liberty and conserve judicial resources. | June 19, 2025 | National, South Carolina | 403, Child Sexual Abuse, Evidence, Expert Testimony, Forensics, Penile Plethysmograph Evidence, Sentencing, Witnesses | national south-carolina | 403 testimony-about-child-sexual-abuse evidence expert-testimony forensics penile-plethysmograph-evidence sentencing witnesses | |
| Motion to Exclude Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome (CSAAS) Testimony | This motion challenges a forensic child abuse investigator’s attempt to bolster a child complainant’s credibility in a sexual assault case through testimony about Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome (CSAAS). Drawing on social science and precedent, the motion argues that CSAAS testimony is not admissible under FRE 702 & Daubert because it is not scientifically reliable (pp. 15-19), has not been tested or subjected to peer review (pp. 19-24), and is not generally accepted (pp. 24-27). The danger of unfair prejudice also substantially outweighs any probative value such that it is inadmissible under FRE 403 (pp. 35-38), and CSAAS testimony is not helpful and improperly invades the jury’s province to determine witness credibility (pp. 38-40). The motion applies to testimony by a forensic examiner about alleged common responses of child sexual assault victims to abuse, including secrecy, helplessness, accommodation, delayed disclosure, and recantation (pp. 32-33). | March 7, 2025 | Maryland, National | 403, Child Sexual Abuse, Evidence, Expert Testimony, Witnesses | maryland national | 403 testimony-about-child-sexual-abuse evidence expert-testimony witnesses | |
| Amicus brief in support of admitting expert testimony on the science of false memories in a child sexual abuse prosecution | Pgs. 7-8 – summarize scientific research describing how people create entirely false memories, a study of false memory creation, and a list of false memory risk factors, particularly for children. Pgs. 9-10 – explain how interview techniques can create false memories in children, even false memories that do not seem to directly relate to the questions asked by the interviewer, and why expert testimony is needed to educate the jury on the counterintuitive nature of memory creation (i.e., the more detailed a memory, the higher the likelihood of error). Pgs. 12-14 argue that, because the science behind false memories is similar to that of mistaken eyewitness identifications and both require jury education to evaluate witness credibility, expert testimony on false memories should be admitted at the discretion of the trial judge under the same logic. | July 29, 2022 | National, Pennsylvania | Age, Child Sexual Abuse, Confessions, Evidence, Expert Testimony, Eyewitness Identification, False Confessions, Identifications, Witnesses | national pennsylvania | age testimony-about-child-sexual-abuse confessions evidence expert-testimony eyewitness-identification false-confessions identifications witnesses custodialinterrogation | |
| Motion to Preclude Expert – Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome | Overview of flaws in proposed testimony explaining how children respond in aftermath of sexual abuse | February 25, 2021 | 10th Cir., National | Child Sexual Abuse, Evidence, Expert Testimony, Witnesses | 10th-cir national | testimony-about-child-sexual-abuse evidence expert-testimony witnesses |