Document Category: Facial Recognition
| Title | Content | Date Filed | Jurisdiction | Categories | Link | hf:doc_author | hf:doc_categories |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Motion to Suppress Evidence Obtained Following Arrest Based Solely on Facial Recognition Technology | This motion argues that an unverified facial recognition alert cannot, without independent corroboration, establish probable cause for an arrest and that evidence obtained through such an arrest must be suppressed. Drawing on expert testimony and scientific research, including a 2024 National Academies report on facial recognition technology, the motion explains how image quality, database composition, algorithmic error rates, demographic disparities, and the absence of trained human review undermine the reliability of automated facial recognition identifications. The motion emphasizes that facial recognition results should be treated as investigative leads rather than positive identifications, particularly when the underlying images, algorithms, and error-rate data have not been preserved or disclosed. The motion further argues that the exclusionary rule applies notwithstanding the existence of an outstanding arrest warrant because officers relied on unverified technology, failed to follow departmental safeguards, and used excessive force without confirming the individual’s identity. It challenges the application of the independent source, inevitable discovery, and attenuation exceptions, emphasizing that reckless or flagrant police misconduct warrants suppression to deter future constitutional violations. | November 3, 2026 | Louisiana, National | 4th Amendment, Evidence, Expert Testimony, Facial Recognition, Forensics, Identifications, Police, Race | louisiana national | 4th-amendment evidence expert-testimony facial-recognition forensics identifications police race witnesses | |
| Amicus arguing that every step of a facial recognition search—the probe photo, database used, photo editing, algorithmic search, and human review—must be disclosed under Brady v. Maryland. | Because each stage of Facial Recognition (FR) carries a risk of error, due process and Brady require disclosure concerning every step (pp. 6–7). The five steps are: (1) the probe photo used, (2) the database selected, (3) any photo editing performed, (4) the algorithmic search, and (5) human review (pp. 6, 9–13). The brief explains that FR has particularly high error rates when applied to people of color, women, elders, and children (p. 8). Low-quality or edited probe photos increase error (pp. 10–11), and many FR databases are skewed by overrepresentation of minorities (pp. 12–13). Algorithms operate as “black boxes” with differing reliability (p. 13), while human review is subject to the same biases as eyewitness identification (p. 13). Because the risk of error varies at each stage and may be exculpatory, defense counsel is entitled to full discovery of the FR process, including the algorithm and analyst, both of whom function as impeachable “witnesses” (pp. 26–27). Defenders can use this brief to argue for comprehensive discovery of FR methods and to frame challenges to the admissibility or reliability of FR-based identifications. | May 28, 2025 | National, New Jersey | 403, 4th Amendment, Discovery, Evidence, Facial Recognition, Identifications, Race | national new-jersey | 403 4th-amendment discovery evidence facial-recognition identifications race forensics | |
| Affidavit of Expert in Facial Recognition Technology | This document was filed in support of a motion to compel discovery of the underlying source code, parameters, error rates, input data, results, reports, analyst, and confidence scores of the Facial Recognition program used in a criminal case. The expert explains the steps involved in a facial recognition search and areas where subjective human decisions — and cognitive bias — are likely to impact the outcome of the search. | June 25, 2021 | D.C., National | 4th Amendment, Evidence, Facial Recognition, Police, Race | d-c national | 4th-amendment evidence facial-recognition police race forensics | |
| False Arrest & Imprisonment Complaint – inaccuracy and racial bias in facial recognition technology | Civil rights complaint about problems with facial recognition technology – pgs. 9-12 collect research about errors with when images are of low quality, angles are different, resolution is bad; pgs. 12-15 collect research showing facial recognition algorithms are racially biased; pgs. 15-16 collect data about jurisdictions that have banned use of facial recognition technology because of its flaws | April 13, 2021 | Michigan, National | 4th Amendment, Evidence, Facial Recognition, Police, Race | michigan national | 4th-amendment evidence facial-recognition police race forensics |