This brief argues that the Alaska Constitution requires police to suspend substantive questioning and clarify when a person makes an ambiguous or equivocal reference to counsel during custodial interrogation. It collects case law from eight other states that have adopted this more protective rule despite Davis v. United States’s decision that, under the federal constitution, all invocations must be clear and unambiguous (pp. 16-21). The brief talks about the problems with the Reid interrogation method (pp. 6-7), the frequency and strength of false confessions in criminal cases (pp. 5-10), and how vulnerable populations have diminished capacity to understand and invoke Miranda rights (pp. 10-16).
File Type: pdf
File Size: 358 KB
Categories: Age, Confessions, Custodial Interrogation, Disability, False Confessions, Intellectual Disabilities, Invocation, Police, Race